Supreme Court Update: Sheetz v. El Dorado County

1456277065_smaller

Supreme Court Update: Sheetz v. El Dorado County

COUNTY NEXUS

Exaction or impact fees are an important way for local governments to balance the benefits of growth with its impacts on the pre-existing community. Limiting the ability of counties to legislatively enact generally applicable development impact fees would impede our efforts to protect the health and welfare of their communities while ensuring that those who create the need for new community infrastructure fairly bear the costs.

BACKGROUND

A resident of El Dorado County, California  challenged the constitutionality of a traffic mitigation fee required in exchange for a development permit, arguing that the fee violates the Fifth Amendment’s takings clause under the Nollan/Dolan unconstitutional conditions test, which prevents governments from applying exaction fees unless they can demonstrate an essential “nexus” between their interest and the fee charged as well as “rough proportionality” between the fee charged and the proposed impact of the development. This case asks whether Nollan/Dolan is limited to fees issued on an an individual basis or whether it also applies to legislatively enacted, generally applicable impact fees and thereby compels local governments to make case-by-case determinations if such fees are warranted.

NACo ADVOCACY

In a Local Government Legal Center Amicus Brief filed in support of the respondent, NACo argued that counties across the country rely on legislatively adopted impact fees to address the burdensome impacts of new development on the availability and quality of local infrastructure, facilities, programs, and services. Without the ability to impose impact fees, local governments would need to resort to imposing new or increased taxes, displace the anticipated infrastructure costs necessary to meet the needs of new residential and commercial development onto existing residents and businesses or even impose development moratoria in the absence of funds to pay for required infrastructure. Expanding Nollan/Dolan to encompass legislative enacted impact fees could diminish this important policy tool.

CURRENT STATUS

On April 12, the Court issued a narrow 9-0 decision vacating the state court's ruling that Nollan/Dolan does not apply to legislatively-enacted impact fees and remanding the case for another look. While the Court's ruling does create heightened constitutional scrutiny for legislatively-enacted impact fees, it does not prevent local governments from enacting reasonable permitting conditions, including impact fees, via legislation. Learn more about the Court's decision and what it means for counties here. 

Current Supreme Court Term

NACo files amicus briefs in key cases to further county priorities ahead of the Supreme Court.

Learn more

1201461261
Advocacy

NACo Legal Advocacy: Monsanto Company v. Durnell

Monsanto v. Durnell considers a preemption issue that carries substantial implications for counties.

Supreme Court
Advocacy

NACo Legal Advocacy: Olivier v. City of Brandon, Mississippi

In Olivier v. City of Brandon, the U.S. Supreme Court is considering when individuals who have been convicted of violating a local ordinance may later bring a federal civil-rights suit challenging that law. 

Image of Supreme-Court_3.jpg
Advocacy

NACo Legal Advocacy: William Trevor Case v. State of Montana

The question at hand in William Trevor Case v. State of Montana is how the “emergency-aid” exemption to the Fourth Amendment is defined and whether it should require “probable cause,” a higher legal threshold that would be needed to justify officers entering the premises of a home in an emergency-aid scenario. 

Related News

capitol building washington dc
Advocacy

Senate Appropriations Committee releases all twelve appropriations bills

On November 16, the U.S. Senate Appropriations Committee completed its release of draft appropriations text for all twelve Fiscal Year (FY) 2027 funding bills. Currently, the government is funded at FY 2026 levels through a Continuing Resolution that is set to expire on December 11.

A pen rests near a calculator
Advocacy

Senate Funding Bill Delivers a Win for Counties, Delaying OMB's Uniform Guidance Proposed Rule

The Senate Appropriations Committee releases CR language to fund the government until December 11 and delay the OMB proposed rule on Uniform Guidance that governs how every federal grant can be administered, a major win for counties.

Union County, Ore. Commissioner Paul Anderes and Grace Donovan, executive director of Eastern Oregon University’s Rural Engagement and Vitality Center, present their Rural Leaders for Economic Mobility capstone project in May 2026. Photo by Charlie Ban
County News

Innovating Solutions Together: Turning Ideas into Results  

NACo CEO Matt Chase: "Every one of these counties started in the same place: a local vision, followed by a search for ideas. NACo builds the networks that connect county officials and other experts." 

Lincoln County, S.D. Commissioner Jim Schmidt voices his opinion during the NACo Board of Directors meeting during the 2025 Legislative Conference. Photo by Denny Henry
County News

Salute to county leaders: Jim Schmidt

After a mid-term appointment to succeed a late commissioner, Jim Schmidt stayed on the Lincoln County, S.D. Board of Commissioners for 28 years, during which time his county's population grew dramatically, both physically and managerially.

NACIRO members gather at the 2026 NACo Annual Conference.
County News

"Intergovs" celebrate excellence

The National Association of County Intergovernmental Relations Officials (NACIRO) celebrated excellence in county advocacy during its 2026 Annual Business Meeting in New Orleans.

Wisconsin Governor-elect David Crowley and running mate Sarah Godlewski embrace at an election-night event on Nov. 03, 2026 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Photo by John Moore/Getty Images
County News

Midterms advance county officials, Florida property tax cut

Voters advanced several current and former county officials to higher office, but also approved a policy that will threaten county budgets in Florida.

Upcoming Events

Image of GettyImages-894378544.jpg
Webinar

NACo Policy Insider Webinar Series: Understanding the Federal Landscape for Counties, November 19

Join NACo for a bi-weekly webinar offering an overview of the full federal policy landscape impacting counties.

Early childhood education teacher with students
Webinar

H.R. 1 Implementation for Counties: State of Play

Join NACo staff to discuss the state of play on H.R. 1 implementation, including an overview of provisions, what’s coming in the new year and how recent Congressional actions and litigation impact Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and Medicaid for counties. 

Image of GettyImages-894378544.jpg
Webinar

NACo Policy Insider Webinar Series: Understanding the Federal Landscape for Counties, December 3

Join NACo for a bi-weekly webinar offering an overview of the full federal policy landscape impacting counties.

Early childhood education teacher with students
Webinar

H.R. 1 Implementation for Counties: Medicaid Best Practices

Join NACo staff and member counties for a discussion surrounding the challenges of H.R. 1 Medicaid implementation and innovative strategies your county can institute to protect coverage as much as possible.

Early childhood education teacher with students
Webinar

H.R. 1 Implementation for Counties: SNAP Best Practices

Join the NACo Government Affairs and County Practices and Innovations teams to showcase county innovations powering Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) modernization and discuss SNAP legislative and regulatory updates.

Image of GettyImages-894378544.jpg
Webinar

NACo Policy Insider Webinar Series: Understanding the Federal Landscape for Counties, December 17

Join NACo for a bi-weekly webinar offering an overview of the full federal policy landscape impacting counties.